top of page
Search

Which Type of Birth Control Pill is Right for Me?

Birth control pills have revolutionised contraception, offering women control over their reproductive health. With numerous options available, understanding the types of birth control pills and finding one that is right for you can be overwhelming.

Whether you're exploring pills for the first time or considering switching, this guide simplifies the choices and equips you with the information needed to make an informed decision.

Key Takeaways

  • Birth control pills are categorised into combination pills and progestin-only pills, with further subtypes based on hormone composition and dosage.

  • Factors like health conditions, lifestyle, and individual goals influence the choice of a suitable pill.

  • While generally safe, each type of pill has potential side effects, advantages, and risks that should be discussed with a doctor.

  • Switching between pills requires professional guidance to maintain effectiveness and minimise possible side effects.

What is the Birth Control Pill?

What is the Birth Control Pill?

The birth control pill, often referred to as "the pill," is a widely used method of oral contraception that offers women an effective, convenient, and reversible way to prevent pregnancy. It functions by regulating the body’s hormone levels to create an environment where conception is unlikely to occur. Specifically, the pill works through three primary mechanisms:

  • Preventing Ovulation

    Ovulation, or the release of an egg from the ovaries, is a crucial step in the conception process. Birth control pills suppress the hormones that trigger ovulation, ensuring that no egg is available for fertilisation by sperm.

  • Thickening Cervical Mucus

    Birth control pills cause cervical mucus to become thicker and stickier, creating a barrier that makes it difficult for sperm to travel through the cervix to reach an egg.

  • Thinning the Uterine Lining

    The pill reduces the thickness of the endometrial lining (the tissue that lines the uterus). This makes it less likely for a fertilised egg, if one were to form, to implant and develop into a pregnancy.

When taken consistently and correctly, birth control pills boast a high efficacy rate, preventing more than 99% of pregnancies. This reliability has made them one of the most popular contraceptive choices worldwide.

What are the different types of Birth Control Pills?

What are the different types of Birth Control Pills? combined oral contraceptive pills progestin-only pills

Combined Oral Contraceptive Pill (COCP)

Combined oral contraceptive pill (COCPs) or the combination pill is the most commonly used type of birth control pill, combining two synthetic hormones - estrogen and progestin - to prevent pregnancy. These pills work through multiple mechanisms: they suppress ovulation to prevent the release of an egg, thicken cervical mucus to block sperm from reaching the egg, and thin the uterine lining to prevent the implantation of a fertilized egg.

The COCP's dual-hormone composition makes them effective and versatile, catering to a wide range of contraceptive needs while offering additional non-contraceptive benefits such as acne reduction and menstrual cycle regulation.

Combination pills are further divided into subtypes based on their hormone dosage and pattern of use, allowing for tailored solutions that align with individual preferences and health conditions. The two primary categories within combination pills are monophasic pills and multiphasic pills (biphasic and triphasic), each offering unique benefits and considerations.

Monophasic Pills

Monophasic pills provide a uniform dose of estrogen and progestin throughout the active pill cycle. This consistent dosage simplifies the regimen and makes it easier for users to adhere to the routine.

These pills are typically taken for 21 or 24 consecutive days, followed by a 7-day or 4-day break, respectively. This break is either a pill-free interval or a time during which inactive pills are taken. This leads to two common regimens: the 21+7 and the 24+4 formats.

In the 21+7 regimen, a user takes 21 active hormone pills followed by 7 inactive pills, during which a withdrawal bleed, similar to a period, occurs. Traditionally, this is the most common schedule, providing a familiar rhythm that mirrors the natural 28-day menstrual cycle.

The 24+4 regimen is a more recent innovation, aimed at offering improved hormonal stability. In this format, the user takes 24 active pills followed by 4 inactive pills. The shorter placebo window results in fewer hormone-free days, which may help reduce hormone withdrawal symptoms such as headaches or mood changes, and in some cases, improve effectiveness slightly by narrowing the margin for error if a pill is missed.

Monophasic pills are ideal for users seeking predictability. The uniform dose minimises hormonal fluctuations, which can help alleviate side effects like mood swings or irregular bleeding. They are especially beneficial for women new to hormonal contraception or those who have had difficulty tolerating variable hormone levels in the past.

Common examples of monophasic pills include Ethinyl estradiol + drospirenone and Ethinyl estradiol + levonorgestrel. These formulations are known for their effectiveness and tolerability.

Advantages of Monophasic Pills

  • Easy to use with a straightforward dosage schedule.

  • Minimal adjustments or monitoring are required, which is ideal for first-time users or those with busy lifestyles.

  • Contribute to predictable menstrual cycles, reducing uncertainty from irregular periods.

  • It can help alleviate non-contraceptive issues like acne, excessive bleeding, and severe cramps.

Disadvantages of Monophasic Pills

  • Increased risk of cardiovascular complications for women over 35 who smoke or have certain health conditions (e.g., blood clots) due to estrogen.

  • Potential side effects include nausea, breast tenderness, and weight changes, varying by individual hormone sensitivity.

Biphasic and Triphasic Pills

Biphasic and triphasic pills, collectively referred to as multiphasic pills, are designed to more closely mimic the body’s natural hormonal fluctuations over the course of the menstrual cycle. Unlike monophasic pills, which maintain a constant hormone level, multiphasic pills adjust the dosage of estrogen and/or progestin at different stages of the cycle. Biphasic pills typically feature two phases of hormone levels, while triphasic pills offer three.

This variation is intended to reduce hormone-related side effects and improve the body’s tolerance to the pill. Women who experience side effects like bloating, mood swings, or breast tenderness with monophasic pills may find relief with biphasic or triphasic options.

Advantages of Biphasic and Triphasic Pills

  • Tailored hormonal delivery reduces side effects for women sensitive to hormonal changes.

  • Mimic the body’s natural cycle, offering a more physiological experience.

  • Different formulations allow doctors to match pills to individual needs.

Disadvantages of Biphasic and Triphasic Pills

  • The hormonal variation adds complexity to the regimen.

  • Users must follow the prescribed order of pills to ensure effectiveness, which can be challenging.

  • Women sensitive to hormonal changes may still experience side effects due to slight hormone level shifts.

Choosing the Right Combination Pill

The choice between monophasic and multiphasic pills ultimately depends on an individual’s health profile, lifestyle, and personal preferences. While monophasic pills are ideal for those seeking simplicity and predictable cycles, biphasic and triphasic options may be better suited for women who require a more nuanced approach to hormone management.

A consultation with a doctor is essential to determine the most appropriate option, taking into account medical history, risk factors, and contraceptive goals.

Progestin-only Pills

What are the different types of Birth Control Pills? progestin-only pills

Progestin-only pills (POPs), also known as minipills, are a type of birth control pill that does not contain estrogen and only contain progestin, making them a preferred choice for women who cannot tolerate estrogen or have medical conditions that may be aggravated by it.

These medical conditions may include migraines, high blood pressure, and a history of blood clots. POPs are particularly suitable for women who want effective contraception without the potential risks associated with estrogen-based pills.

Examples of progestin-only pills include Norethindrone-containing and Drospirenone-containing pills which are commonly prescribed for their effectiveness in preventing pregnancy without the side effects that estrogen might cause.

Advantages of Progestin-Only Pills

  • Safe for Breastfeeding Women

    One of the most significant benefits of POPs is that they are safe for use during breastfeeding. Estrogen can affect milk production, which is why progestin-only pills are often recommended for postpartum women who wish to prevent pregnancy without interfering with lactation. POPs do not impact the milk supply, making them a reliable choice for new mothers.

  • Lower Risk of Cardiovascular Side Effects

    Since POPs do not contain estrogen, they carry a lower risk of cardiovascular side effects, such as deep vein thrombosis (DVT), blood clots, and strokes. Estrogen is known to elevate the risk of these conditions, especially in women over 35 who are smokers, or those with existing cardiovascular issues. Progestin-only pills do not have this risk, making them safer for women with such health concerns.

Disadvantages of Progestin-Only Pills

  • Strict Adherence to Timing

    One of the most significant challenges with POPs is that they must be taken at the same time every day, without fail. Even a delay of more than three hours in taking a pill can reduce its effectiveness and increase the risk of pregnancy. This strict schedule can be inconvenient, especially for women with busy lifestyles or irregular routines. Adherence to timing is critical to maintain their contraceptive reliability.

  • Irregular Bleeding

    POPs may cause irregular bleeding patterns, especially in the first few months of use. Women may experience spotting, lighter or heavier periods, or even the absence of periods altogether. While these changes are generally not harmful, they can be bothersome for some women. If irregular bleeding persists or becomes severe, it is important to consult a doctor to rule out other underlying issues.

How do Progestin-only Pills differ from Combined Pills?

How do Progestin-only Pills differ from Combined Pills?

Hormonal Composition

Effectiveness in Regulating Menstrual Cycles

  • COCs are generally more effective at regulating menstrual cycles. They can help reduce heavy bleeding, cramps, and irregular periods, making them a good option for women with menstrual cycle concerns.

  • POPs, on the other hand, do not regulate menstrual cycles as effectively and can lead to irregular bleeding or spotting. This makes them less ideal for women looking for consistent cycle control.

Health Benefits Beyond Contraception

  • COCs offer additional health benefits beyond contraception, such as improving acne, reducing symptoms of endometriosis, and managing PCOS.

  • POPs do not provide these additional benefits since they lack estrogen, which plays a role in managing these conditions.

Risks and Suitability for Certain Health Conditions

  • The estrogen in COCs can increase the risk of blood clots, heart attacks, and strokes, especially in women who smoke, are over 35, or have a history of cardiovascular issues.

  • POPs, which do not contain estrogen, are safer for women with health conditions such as migraines with aura, high blood pressure, or a history of blood clots. They are also a preferred option for breastfeeding women because they do not affect milk production.

Strictness of Adherence to Timing

  • POPs require very strict adherence to the timing of taking the pill, as missing a dose or taking it late can significantly reduce their effectiveness.

  • COCs are slightly more forgiving when it comes to timing; taking a pill a few hours late typically doesn’t affect its effectiveness.

Side Effects

  • Both types of pills can cause side effects, but they vary depending on the individual. COCs may cause mood swings, nausea, or weight changes due to the estrogen component.

  • POPs may also cause mood changes and irregular bleeding. Some women find POPs lead to more frequent spotting, which can be a downside.

Ease of Use

  • COCs are generally easier to use in terms of flexibility with timing, as missing a single dose is less likely to result in contraceptive failure.

  • POPs require more precise timing, making them more challenging for women with hectic schedules or those prone to forgetting to take their pill at the same time each day.

Safety During Breastfeeding

  • POPs are considered the safer option for breastfeeding women, as they do not interfere with milk production.

  • COCs, due to the estrogen content, may reduce milk supply, making them less ideal for women who are nursing.

Overall Suitability

  • COCs are better suited for women looking for a method that regulates their cycle, offers additional health benefits, and is comfortable with estrogen-based contraception.

  • POPs are ideal for women who cannot use estrogen, whether due to health concerns or breastfeeding, or those seeking a simple contraceptive method without affecting their cycle too much.

What are the different types of Progestins?

What are the different types of Progestins?

Progestin, the synthetic version of the hormone progesterone, is the active ingredient in POPs and COCPs. There are various types of progestins used in birth control pills, and each type can have slightly different effects on the body. Understanding these different forms can help women choose the right option for their health and lifestyle.

Here are some common types of progestins:

Norethindrone

  • Norethindrone is one of the most widely used forms of progestins in POPs. It is a synthetic progestin that closely mimics natural progesterone.

  • Norethindrone is often chosen because of its long track record of safety and effectiveness in preventing pregnancy.

  • This progestin is known to be effective in suppressing ovulation and thickening cervical mucus to prevent sperm from reaching the egg.

Drospirenone

  • Drospirenone is a synthetic progestin that has similar properties to natural progesterone but also exhibits mild anti-androgenic effects, meaning it can help reduce symptoms like acne or excessive hair growth.

  • Drospirenone is often preferred by women who also want additional benefits, like managing acne or improving skin tone.

  • While drospirenone is effective in contraception, it can also slightly reduce water retention, which may help with bloating, a common concern among some women on birth control.

Desogestrel

  • Desogestrel is another commonly used progestin, known for its high efficacy in preventing pregnancy.

  • Desogestrel is known for having a lower risk of side effects related to weight gain and mood changes compared to other progestins.

  • This progestin works by preventing ovulation and thickening cervical mucus. It is particularly suitable for women looking for a reliable birth control method without significant hormonal fluctuations.

Levonorgestrel

  • Levonorgestrel is another synthetic progestin used in various forms of contraception.

  • Levonorgestrel is a progestin that works similarly to other types by thickening cervical mucus and preventing ovulation.

  • Though effective, levonorgestrel can cause more noticeable side effects in some women, such as changes in menstrual bleeding patterns or mood swings.

Etonogestrel

  • Etonogestrel is more commonly found in implants and vaginal rings.

  • Like other forms of progestin, etonogestrel works by inhibiting ovulation and altering the cervical mucus.

  • It is less frequently used in oral contraception but is known for its high efficacy and relatively low side effects.

How to Choose the Right Birth Control Pill for You

How to Choose the Right Pill for You

Choosing the right birth control pill isn’t always a straightforward decision depends on a variety of factors, including your health conditions, lifestyle and preferences. Here are some key considerations:

  • Health Conditions

    Certain health conditions may affect which type of pill is best for you. For example, women with a history of blood clots may need a different pill than those without such a condition. It is important to consult a doctor to ensure that the pill you choose is safe and effective for your health needs.

    If you are sensitive to hormonal changes or have experienced negative side effects in the past, you may prefer a monophasic pill. These pills maintain a steady hormone level, which can help minimize fluctuations and discomfort.

  • Lifestyle and Convenience

    Consider your ability to follow a complex pill regimen. If you have a busy lifestyle or may find it difficult to remember multiple types of pills throughout the month, a monophasic pill may be the best option. On the other hand, if you’re comfortable with a more intricate regimen and desire a pill that mimics the body’s natural cycle, biphasic or triphasic pills may be a better fit.

By discussing these factors with your doctor, you can make a more informed decision about which birth control pill aligns best with your needs.

Switching Pills: What You Need to Know

Switching Pills: What You Need to Know

Switching from one type of birth control pill to another may become necessary for various reasons, including side effects or evolving health needs. However, this process should always be approached with the guidance of a qualified doctor to ensure safety and effectiveness. Here’s what to keep in mind:

Reasons for Switching

  • Side Effects

    If you experience persistent issues like nausea, mood swings, headaches, or weight fluctuations, your doctor may recommend a different formulation that aligns better with your body’s hormonal response.

  • Health Changes

    New medical conditions, such as migraines with aura or high blood pressure, might make a particular type of pill less suitable, prompting the need for an alternative.

  • Lifestyle Adjustments

    Changes in your routine or personal preferences may also influence your choice. For instance, a progestin-only pill might be ideal if you are breastfeeding or prefer a lower hormonal dose.

Timing and Transition

  • Ensuring Continuous Coverage

    Proper timing is essential to avoid any gap in contraceptive protection. Your doctor will advise on whether to complete your current pack before starting the new one or begin the new pack immediately to overlap.

  • Individualized Guidance

    Factors like the type of pill you’re switching to (e.g., combined to progestin-only or vice versa) and your health profile will determine the best strategy. Following professional guidance minimises the risk of unintended pregnancy and ensures your body adjusts smoothly to the new medication.

Switching birth control pills is a personalised process. Always communicate openly with your doctor about your symptoms, concerns, and preferences to find the option that works best for you.

Conclusion

Choosing the right birth control pill is a personal decision that depends on several factors, including your health conditions, lifestyle, and preferences. Whether you opt for a monophasic, biphasic, or triphasic pill, it is important to work with a doctor to find the best option for you. By understanding the differences between these pills, you can make an informed choice that works best for your body and your lifestyle.


Frequently Asked Questions

  • How do I switch from one pill to another safely?

    Switching requires consultation with a doctor. Overlapping pills or direct transitions may be recommended, with backup contraception if needed.

  • Can birth control pills cause weight gain?

    Most modern pills have minimal impact on weight. However, individual responses vary, and any concerns should be discussed with a doctor.

  • Do birth control pills protect against STIs?

    No, pills do not offer STI protection. Use condoms for dual protection against pregnancy and infections. Read more here.

Important

This blog, including its text, images, and infographics, is for educational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice. For personalized advice, always consult a doctor.

Further Reading

For more details on this or related topics, refer to the papers listed in references below, or check out the other blogs on our website dulycare.in.

References

Comments

bottom of page